19th century Tlingit double-headed eagle rattle. Source: Metropolitan Museum
The image above is of a Tlingit rattle, with the motif of a double-headed eagle. With the vast repertoire of supernatural beings who could be invoked in the Northwest Coast art, one could be forgiven for thinking this was another of these figures from the rich mythology and history of the Tlingit people.
In fact, this Tlingit rattle is undoubtedly based on the Imperial Russian coat of arms. As I noted yesterday, the Russians were the earliest Europeans into many parts of Alaska. After the Russian-Tlingit Battle of Sitka in 1804, peace talks were conducted and Aleksandr Baranov, the first governor of colonial Russian Alaska and manager of the Russian-America Company, presented the Kiks.adi Sitka Tlingit leaders with a large medallion, on which was found the Russian imperial symbol (below).
Tlingit accounts of the treaty have been presented by Alex Andrews and Mark Jacobs, Jr. In a transcribed interview, Alex Andrews (1960:6-7) explains that the Indians did not know the value of the plaque presented by the Russians, and it was believed to be a retribution or atonement for the dead. He further stated that Baranov came to Peril Straights to negotiate the treaty. Mark Jacobs account of the treaty was related in a speech at the Second Russian-American Conference in 1987:
It was finally decided by the Kiks.adi’s to return and sit down for the peace talks. It was at this peace treaty that the present Castle Hill was given to Baranov in exchange for a double-headed eagle badge, which is depicted on the totem pole [in Totem Square, Sitka]. It was explained to mean, “From now on and forever, we will be brothers. You look one way and we the other way.” The round knob on the bottom of the totem pole represents Castle Hill. The only piece of real estate ever given to the Russians [emphasis in original document]… The double-headed eagle badge, received from the peace talks, is now in the State of Alaska Museum in Juneau [Jacobs 1987:9].
Since that time, the double-headed eagle has been a motif widely used in Tlingit art.
I like to think that the Russians did not fully know what they were doing. Early treaties commonly took advantage of very different indigenous views on the nature of property and land ownership in order to dispossess people of their land under the fig leaf of western law. In this case though, I wonder if the shoe is not on the other foot. Crests were inherited rights on much of the Northwest Coast, yet they could also be traded or shared or given away. The right to display a Crest was a valuable property right that helped establish a lineage’s relative status.
By acquiring the Crest of the Imperial Russian lineage as compensation for their dead, the Tlingit Chiefs may have in effect subordinated the entire Russian aristocracy: a stunning coup in Tlingit terms. The Russians may never have noticed that they had become Lesser Chiefs in their own colony.
Imperial Russian medallion presented by Baranov to Sitka chiefs in 1804. Source: Juneau Empire.
The top image is from the small but sweet exhibition of NW Coast musical instruments at the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
Northwest Coast Archaeology 
