This site contains an inspired argument that Viking Vinland, Markland and Helluland were on the NW Coast. It’s thought-through to a scary degree, in the way that magnificent obsessions often are. Though as I always say, if something isn’t worth doing, it isn’t worth doing well. And based on my acquaintance with NW Coast Archaeology, I have to say that the theory falls down at a few key junctures. Worse, it is part of a long-running narrative in which aboriginal people of the Americas have their finest cultural achievements taken and assigned as the work of Europeans. See, for example, the Vikings in Minnesota theories, which argue that the great mounds of Mississippian Culture were the construction of White Men from the North. Do the Minnesota proponents have academic arguments with the Vancouver Island proponents? Were Vikings everywhere? Is this a racist narrative? Too bad all this energy is not put into something worthwhile, there is so much serious work to do.
qmackie on ‘Namgis Arborglyph qmackie on About Michael Kennedy on About Ron Corbyn on More on Manis Mastodon qmackie on More on Manis Mastodon Ron Corbyn on More on Manis Mastodon qmackie on More on Manis Mastodon qmackie on More on Manis Mastodon qmackie on More on Manis Mastodon qmackie on The Rough Guide to the B.C. Go… ehpem on The Rough Guide to the B.C. Go… Ron Corbyn on More on Manis Mastodon Richard Michael Gram… on More on Manis Mastodon Ron Corbyn on More on Manis Mastodon Richard Michael Gram… on More on Manis Mastodon
Most viewed posts in last few days
- Jarring Finds
- The Midden, Reborn
- The Bison at Ayer Pond on Orcas Island is archaeological.
- Haida, Argillite, and the Pig War
- Still selling First Nations' Archaeological Heritage
- Images of Nootka Island People, 1787
- Tlingit War Helmet Rediscovered after 100 years
- Compilation of Work from Tse'K'wa (Charlie Lake Cave)
- Klahoose Arborglyph
- Peabody Museum Ethnographic Collection
- alaska anthropology Archaeological Society of BC Archaeological Society of British Columbia Archaeology archives argillite art artifacts ASBC british columbia canoes clovis CMT Coast Salish conservation CRM Culturally Modified Tree Cultural Resource Management Esquimalt ethnohistory First Nations first peopling fish fishing fish traps fish weirs Fraser River Gulf Islands Haida Haida Gwaii Heiltsuk historical archaeology history household archaeology Intertidal Kilgii Gwaay Makah museums Northwest Coast Nuu-chah-nulth Oregon organic technology palaeoenvironment palaeontology petroglyphs pictographs pleistocene pre-clovis Public Archaeology Puget Sound RBCM repatriation rock art Royal BC Museum Salish Salish Sea salmon sculpture Seattle SFU Songhees southeast alaska Straits Salish tlingit ubc underwater archaeology uvic Vancouver Vancouver Island Victoria BC Washington State waterlogged sites wet sites zooarchaeology