Grace Islet – Shmukw’elu – is a small island (map, pic) in Ganges Harbour, Saltspring Island. It is a Coast Salish cemetery, and it is a settler construction site. How do we reconcile these contradictory uses of this island? I’ve been hesitant to post about this case because I know it’s a long and complicated story of how we got to 2014, when we see burial cairns being literally encased into concrete house foundations. I am quite sure that many people of goodwill made many decisions that seemed right to them at the time. I don’t know what all these decisions are, what happened when, exactly, what the consultant said, how the house owner sleeps at night – I just don’t know all these variables and I am schooled in the idea you should know everything before you say anything. It’s clear though that, somehow, the practice of archaeology in this province led to the Grace Islet outcome. Shouldn’t we try to understand the process? That’s fine in principle, but can be silencing in the face of complexity: as Pierre Bourdieu wrote, “the most successful ideological efforts are those which have no need for words, and then ask no more than complicitous silence.” No more silence, then.
Click for RSS feed
-
Join 819 other subscribers
Random Post
Archives
Recent Comments
Devin Mckay on Still selling First Nations… Cynthia on La Brea Woman: Image Cont… Consort Plastics 2.0… on Brainstorming beads Emma F on Photos of Victoria and Esquima… A field guide to Was… on The Skagit River Atlatl Kevin on Arborglyph Delaney on Arborglyph Snaps While Kayaking… on D’Suq’Wub: Old Man House… Michael D on Environmental Archaeology of t… iain on Coast Salish “Woolly Dog… Stephanie Peterson M… on Coast Salish “Woolly Dog… iain on Coast Salish “Woolly Dog… Suquamish traditions… on A Coast Salish Mausoleum,… Dea on La Brea Woman: Image Cont… Lloyd neet on Anchor Stones Most viewed posts in last few days
- Tree Burials at Tsaxis
- La Brea Woman: Image Controversy
- Salish Villages of Puget Sound
- Puget Sound Clovis
- Florida Mammoth Engraving is Real?
- A cool new cave site near Tumbler Ridge?
- Sally Binford
- Two Views of Double-Headed Eagles
- The Bison at Ayer Pond on Orcas Island is archaeological.
- Seated Human Figure Bowl going up for sale?
Follow on Twitter
Northwest Links
- ASBC
- ASBC (Facebook)
- ASBC Victoria
- Association for Washington Archaeology
- Association of Oregon Archaeologists
- BC Archaeology Branch
- BC Archives Search
- BCAPCA
- Bill Reid Centre
- Brian Thom’s Coast Salish Page
- Canadian Archaeology 14C Database
- Clam Garden Network
- Dan Leen's NW Coast Petroglyph Page
- Digital archives – Alaska
- Hakai Institute
- Madonna Moss Blog
- Millennia's Blog
- Native Alaska Collections
- NewsWARP
- Northwest History
- Oregon Archaeology
- PDFs from AMNH
- PSU Blog
- Sealaska Blog
- SFU XRF
- Shelby Anderson Blog
- The Par-Tee Site (Oregon)
- Tla'amin-SFU Archaeology Project
- UBC xwi7xwa Library
- Underwater Archaeological Society of BC
- Virtual Meier Site
- Virtual Xa:ytem
- Voices of the Snuneymuxw First Nation
- Washington State Archaeology Field Guide (PDF)
- Washington State Archaeology Office
- West Point Site, Seattle
Northwest People
- Ackerman, Robert
- Ames, Ken
- Anderson, Shelby
- Angelbeck, Bill
- Archer, David
- Arnold, Jeanne
- Augustine, Skye
- Bell, Lucy
- Blake, Mike
- Boxberger, Daniel
- Boyd, Robert
- Brauner, David
- Burchell, Meghan
- Butler, Virginia
- Byram, Scott
- Campbell, Sarah
- Cannon, Aubrey
- Carlson, Keith
- Carlson, Roy
- Chisholm, Brian
- Clague, John
- Clark, Terence
- Connolly, Tom
- Coupland, Gary
- Crockford, Susan
- Croes, Dale
- Cruikshank, Julie
- Cybulski, Jerome
- Davis, Loren
- Deur, Douglas
- Dixon, Jim
- Driver, Jon
- Easton, Norm
- Eldridge, Morley
- Ewonus, Paul
- Fedje, Daryl
- Fitzhugh, Ben
- Fladmark, Knut
- Frederick, Gay
- Gilsen, Leland
- Graesch, Anthony
- Grier, Colin
- Hanson, Diane
- Harkin, Michael
- Hayden, Brian
- Heaton, Tim
- Hebda, Richard
- Hill, Genevieve
- Huelsbeck, David
- Jenkins, Dennis
- Keddie, Grant
- Kooper, Kory
- La Salle, Marina
- Lacourse, Terri
- Lepofsky, Dana
- Losey, Robert
- Lutz, John
- Lyons, Natasha
- Marshall, Yvonne
- Martindale, Andrew
- Mathewes, Rolf
- Mathews, Darcy
- McIlwraith, Tad
- McKechnie, Iain
- McLaren, Duncan
- McMillan, Alan
- Menzies, Charles
- Miller, Bruce
- Morin, Jesse
- Moss, Madonna
- Muckle, Bob
- Muir, Robert
- Nadasdy, Paul
- Nicholas, George
- Orchard, Trevor
- Peacock, Sandra
- Pokotylo, David
- Prentiss, Anna
- Rahemtulla, Farid
- Reimchen, Tom
- Reimer, Rudy / Yumks
- Salomon, Anne
- Schaepe, David
- Seymour, Brian
- Smith, Nicole F.
- Speller, Camilla
- Stein, Julie
- Stueber, Dan
- Supernant, Kisha
- Thom, Brian
- Turner, Nancy
- Tushingham, Shannon
- Ward, Brent
- Welch, John
- Wickwire, Wendy
- Wigen, Becky
- Wilson, Doug
- Yang, Dongya
- Yellowhorn, Eldon
- Yesner, David
Other Blogs & Sites
- alaska anthropology Archaeological Society of BC Archaeological Society of British Columbia Archaeology archives argillite art artifacts ASBC british columbia canoes clovis CMT Coast Salish conservation CRM Cultural Resource Management Esquimalt ethnohistory First Nations first peopling fish fishing fish traps fish weirs Fraser River Gulf Islands Haida Haida Gwaii Heiltsuk historical archaeology history household archaeology Intertidal Kilgii Gwaay Makah maps museums Northwest Coast Nuu-chah-nulth Oregon organic technology palaeoenvironment palaeontology petroglyphs pictographs pleistocene pre-clovis Public Archaeology Puget Sound RBCM repatriation rock art Royal BC Museum Salish Salish Sea salmon sculpture Seattle SFU Songhees southeast alaska Straits Salish tlingit ubc underwater archaeology uvic Vancouver Vancouver Island Victoria BC Washington State waterlogged sites wet sites zooarchaeology